Practically Speaking by FOIMan

Recently I was fortunate enough to be asked to take part in a panel discussion at City University about the Justice Select Committee’s post-legislative scrutiny of FOI. After each of us had said our piece, we got to my favourite part of these kind of events – questions from the audience. And one student journalist asked whether it was right that FOI Officers often shared details of requests from journalists with Press Officers in their organisations. Wasn’t it wrong that FOI Officers should feel an obligation to work with the spin doctors?

There is obviously a debate around how closely FOI Officers should work with Press Officers on FOI requests. But the thrust of my response was that FOI Officers DO have an obligation to their organisation. We do a job. Our organisations pay our wages.  Whilst many FOI Officers do take a principled approach to their work, ultimately they have to do what their employer tells them.

One of the principal aims of my blog (http://www.foiman.com/) when I started it was to talk about FOI from the perspective of the practitioner. And FOI from the practitioner’s perspective is very much a practical exercise. Hopefully it is clear from the way I write that I am a supporter of FOI and increasing openness in the public sector and beyond. But fundamentally I have to make FOI work on a day-to-day basis. That isn’t always easy.

And recently I’ve been running a training course for Act Now Training where we’ve explored what it really means to be an FOI Officer. What are the practical skills that an FOI Officer needs?

The obvious thing is knowledge of the legislation, and that technical side of the role gets plenty of attention. What needs to go into a response? How do you refuse vexatious requests? Where do you go for help?

Before we can even begin to answer requests, we need to know how to arm our organisations with the right IT systems, get our websites FOI-friendly, and ensure that records are being well managed. On the course we discuss the pros and cons of disclosure logs. Can they help reduce the volume of FOI requests or do they provoke more?

But the part of the course that gets us most animated is when we look at dealing with scepticism from colleagues. Every FOI Officer has encountered resistance from time to time, and to me, knowing how to deal with that is probably the most important part of the job. Most of the time opposition to FOI within public bodies is not about any strong political opposition to the legislation. It’s about ordinary people who care as much about their job as we FOI Officers do about ours. Or journalists do about theirs. To persuade them to adjust their priorities is a matter of patience and diplomacy. When we’re at our best!

If you’re an FOI Officer and want to go back to basics, or just explore the different aspects of your role with fellow practitioners, I’ll be running Practical FOI once more this year in a couple of weeks’ time on 16 November in London. And there will be more next year if you can’t make that date.

Paul Gibbons runs the very popular FOI Man Blog and tweets as @FoIManUK.

FOI Review : What to Expect

Last year the Justice Select Committee, chaired by Sir Alan Beith, launched a call for written evidence for its post-legislative scrutiny of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOI). The Committee invited written evidence on the following issues (although those responding were free to discuss other matters):

  • Does the Freedom of Information Act work effectively?
  • What are the strengths and weaknesses of the Freedom of Information Act?
  • Is the Freedom of Information Act operating in the way that it was intended to?

The Committee has now finished hearing oral evidence. Its website contains more details including dates of hearings as well as uncorrected transcripts of evidence. Whilst much has been written and submitted to the Committee about what changes the Government should make to the FOI regime, some changes are more likely to be recommended by it than others:

1. A new exemption for Frivolous Requests

The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has told the Committee (and a recent conference) that it would be in favour of an exemption being introduced to alleviate the burden of frivolous requests e.g. for zombie invasion plans.

My view is that this is a sacrificial lamb being offered by the ICO to try and deflect some of the recent criticism directed towards it. Public authorities have claimed that the ICO is not doing enough to help them at a time when they are being inundated with nuisance requests that clearly have no purpose or value. However the Committee may feel it needs to go further to address such concerns.

2. A Change to the Costs Regime

Many of those that have responded to the Committee’s call for evidence, have expressed concern about the sheer cost of dealing with FOI requests, although the basis of calculation of some of the figures seem highly dubious. It is likely that changes are made to allow more activities to be included as part of the costs limit of £450/£600 limit (under the Freedom of Information and Data Protection (Appropriate Limit and Fees) Regulations 2004) including perhaps the time it takes to redact exempt information from a document before disclosing the latter.

It seems that the Government is already pre judging the outcome of the Committee’s report. According to a BBC Newsnight report on 5th April 2012, a new fees regime could be introduced to reduce the number of FOI requests. Different tariffs could be used to charge different types of requestors. For more on this read Jonathan Baines excellent guest post for the Save FOI Blog.

3. A new Cabinet Minutes Exemption

The previous Government has on two occasions used the ministerial veto (under section 53) to exempt disclosure of cabinet minutes.  On 24th February 2009 the then Lord Chancellor, Jack Straw, issued the first ever ministerial veto  (See Cabinet Office and Christopher Lamb v IC (EA/2008/0024 & 0029)) when the Tribunal decided to uphold the ruling by the Information Commissioner that minutes of cabinet meetings from 2003 discussing the Iraq War should be disclosed.  On 10th December 2009, Mr Straw did the same again in respect of a decision of the Commissioner (Cabinet Office FS50100665) requiring disclosure of minutes of the Cabinet Ministerial Committee on devolution to Scotland and Wales and the English Regions in 1997.

Dominic Grieve, the Attorney General, also used the veto to block release of Cabinet Minutes relating to Scottish and Welsh Devolution. Recently the Health Secretary, Andrew Lansley, caused controversy when he used the veto to block access to the NHS Risk Register. On each occasion the veto has been used, the Commissioner has issued a report to Parliament expressing disappointment. However recently he has said that if the Government feels strongly about Cabinet Minutes being kept secret then an absolute exemption should be introduced. Bearing in mind what the Prime Minister and Lord O’ Donnel (the former head of the civil service) have said about FOI recently, this is a strong possibility.

4. Other Possible Changes

Looking at the various submissions to the Committee especially those from the ICO, it is also likely that statutory limits for Internal Reviews and the public interest test are recommended to avoid delays in dealing with requests. It may also be recommended that now FOI has bedded in, the role of the Qualified Person (under section 36) be removed so that there is no delay in Refusal Notices being issued where this exemption is claimed.

The Committee is due to report before the Summer Recess of Parliament.

Ibrahim Hasan is doing a web seminar on the changes to the FOI, DPA and RIPA regime to be made by the Protection of Freedoms Act. Click Here  for more information.

FOI Man in Training

We are pleased to announce that Paul Gibbons, aka FOI Man, is doing two workshops for us on “Practical FOI: How to Make FOI Work in Your Organisation”. Paul is a very experienced FOI Officer currently working in the university sector. Before that he spent many years as a records manager in both the private and public sectors.Paul runs the very popular FOI Man Blog and tweets as @FoIManUK.

This is what he says about his new Practical FOI Course for Act Now Training:

“One or two of you may have noticed that I’m branching out. Act Now Training have kindly asked me to develop and run a training course on Practical FOI.

Now I know there are lots of training courses on FOI out there, so what’s special about this course?

Well, as the name suggests, this isn’t about complicated legal arguments on the application of exemptions. This is about what you actually need to do if you’re an FOI Officer – especially if you’re new to the job.

You can find other courses that will cover one aspect of being an FOI Officer, but Practical FOI goes over the basics of everything that you’ll need to do.

We’ll be looking at ways to raise awareness amongst colleagues. Discussing the best methods for logging FOI requests. Picking out what you really need to do to improve your organisation’s records management.

We’ll talk about how to deal with colleagues who don’t want to answer FOI requests. And what procedures you need in place to manage complaints.

I look forward to helping you work out how to make FOI work in practice.”

Practical FOI is running in Manchester and London. Book Now to avoid disappointment.

Protection of Freedoms Act 2012

Protection of Freedoms Act 2012

 2012 CHAPTER 9

The Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 received Royal Assent on 1st May 2012. The Act contains a number of measures which, when brought into force, will have a major impact on public authorities especially councils. Amongst other things the Act:

Introduces a new code of practice for surveillance camera systems. This is in addition to the CCTV Code of Practice under the Data Protection Act 1998. There will also be a surveillance camera commissioner. Read our article on  the New CCTV Regime 

  • Extends the Freedom of Information Act by requiring datasets to be made available in a re-usable electronic format. Read our blog entry on how this can make you money. For details of an innovative use of a dataset click here
  • Provides for Magistrates’ approval of all surveillance activities by local authorities under RIPA. Read a full article on the changes.
  • Requires schools to obtain parents’ consent before processing children’s biometric information
  • Restrict the scope of the ‘vetting and barring’ scheme for protecting vulnerable groups and makes changes to the system of criminal records checks. Read our article

Ibrahim Hasan is doing a special online training session  on the new Act in June and July.

The Act will also:

  • bring in a new framework for police retention of fingerprints and DNA data
  • provide for a code of practice to cover officials’ powers of entry, with these powers being subject to review and repeal
  • outlaw wheel-clamping on private land
  • introduce a new regime for police stops and searches under the Terrorism Act 2000 and reduces the maximum pre-charge detention period under that Act from 28 to 14 days
  • enable those with convictions for consensual sexual relations between men aged 16 or over (which have since been decriminalised) to apply to have them disregarded

All our information and surveillance law courses will be updated to take account of the new Act. If you would like customised in house training on any aspects of the Act, please get in touch.

FearSquare : A Dataset to be Feared?

A recently launched mobile phone application provides a useful insight into what could be possible if public authority datasets are fully exploited.

Many datasets are routinely published  by public authorities and are available for re use at little or no cost. Others can be accessed by making a request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOI). The Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 , which received Royal Assent on 1st May 2011, will make access and re use of datasets much easier. Once the Act is brought into force, amongst other things, it will amend FOI so that in the future public authorities will have greater obligations in relation to the release and publication of datasets. The key points are:

  • There will be a new duty on public authorities, when releasing datasets, to adhere to any request to do so in electronic form which allows its re-use where reasonably practicable.
  • Any dataset containing copyright material (where the authority holds the copyright) must be made available for re-use under a specified licence.
  • Publication schemes will in future contain a requirement to publish datasets, which have been requested, as well as any updated versions.
  • Such datasets will also have to be published in an electronic form capable of re use and any copyright material must be available for re use in accordance with the terms of a specified licence.

On the face of it, these obligations seem onerous. However they may also bring an opportunity for public authorities to raise some much needed revenue. They will be able to charge a fee (and make a profit) for allowing re use of any datasets containing copyright material (Read Ibrahim Hasan’s detailed article on the dataset provisions).

Once datasets are released, the idea is that clever people out there will think of innovative uses for them. This may involve a “mash up” with other data. One example is Fearsquare. Its website states:

“FearSquare is an application which allows FourSquare** users in the UK to easily see the official crime statistics for the places where you ‘check-in’. The intention is to give you a uniquely individual look at the levels and types of crimes you are exposed to in your daily life.”

** If you are not “cool” and “with it” like me, go to the end of this blog post for a brief explanation of Foursquare.

Foursquare knows all the locations that a user visits most often. These may be areas with high levels of recorded crime or are known for specific types of crime. For example, a user may be contemplating walking in an unfamiliar area where there have been a lot of muggings. FearSquare aims to keep the user updated on their surroundings and the levels and types of crimes recorded nearby. After all, forewarned is forearmed!

Fearsquare takes its crime stats from the UK Police Crime Statistics database. It has a “leaderboard” of the most dangerous areas based on the crime reported. The leaderboard gives out points to the most crime-heavy areas based on the types of infractions that take place, be it robbery or weapons related crimes.The site also has a real-time ticker that displays check-ins that have unlocked crime statistics, which serves as another way of discovering places that a user should be weary of visiting alone.

Interestingly there is a “game” built into FearSquare. The bold and the brave are awarded points when they visit the most crime-ridden areas in the UK. I think I will stick to establishments offering Nectar Points!

Fearsquare is the brainchild of Lincoln Social Computing Research Centre(part of the University of Lincoln) and is part of a study looking at how this sort of personalised data could change user behaviour. It is a good example of an innovative use of an openly available dataset. Public authorities need to start work now on identifying useful datasets they hold and raising awareness amongst stakeholder departments as to how they could be exploited. This opportunity, which should not be left to the private sector alone, nor should it be the realm of those who are motivated by profit.

Now if Dorothy or Little Red Riding Hood had this app on their mobile phones, i wonder which route they would they have taken?

NB Foursquare is an application (very popular in the US, less so here) which allows users to use the location services on their mobile phone to electronically “check in” at various locations; from coffee shops, pubs and restaurants to supermarkets. More check ins mean prizes as well as the much-envied status of “mayor” of a certain location. See https://foursquare.com/about/ for more.

New Webinar– For more on this and other aspects of the Protection of Freedoms Act, join us on our one-hour online seminar: http://www.actnow.org.uk/courses/city_ONLINE

Access to Social Work Records of the Deceased

Local authorities often receive Freedom of Information Act (FOI) requests for access to the social work records of the deceased. These usually come from family members, sometimes to assist them with a dispute or a legal claim. When making a decision about disclosure, Social Services staff are required to assess the privacy of the living as well as the dead.

Sometimes the exemption under section 41 of FOI (Breach of Confidence) can be used to refuse access to information about the deceased. This applies where a disclosure of confidential information, obtained from another party, would lead to an actionable Breach of Confidence. The leading Information Tribunal case (as it was called then) on this issue (Bluck v Information Commissioner and Epson and St. Helier University Hospitals NHS Trust EA/2006/0090) concerned the disclosure of medical records to the deceased’s mother without the consent of the deceased’s husband.  The Trust’s decision to deny access, based on section 41, was upheld by the Commissioner and the Tribunal.  Both ruled that the duty of confidentiality extends beyond death. If the information was disclosed there was, in theory at least, an actionable Breach of Confidence, which would allow the personal representative of the deceased (her husband) to sue the Trust.

This case was followed by the Information Commissioner in a Decision Notice involving Trafford Metropolitan Borough Council (FS50153179 27/11/2007.)
The complainant asked to see information about her deceased mother which was contained in her mother’s social services records. The Council refused to disclose the information claiming a number of exemptions.

The Commissioner ruled that in respect of the information about and which identified the deceased’s primary carer, the Council was correct to claim the section 40 exemption (personal data). The information included references to the carer’s personal circumstances, her health and financial arrangements. The sensitive nature of the information and the fact that the carer had objected to the release of similar information held by another public authority meant that the disclosure, without consent, would be unfair.

Most of the rest of the requested information was about the deceased. The Commissioner ruled that the section 41 exemption could be claimed. Cleary this information was obtained from another party (i.e. GPs, the primary carer, the deceased etc.) but was it confidential? The Council explained that individuals enter into social services care arrangements with the expectation that the information they provide (both directly and indirectly) will only be used in connection with the provision of that care and will not otherwise be disclosed to third parties without their consent (except in very limited circumstances). The Commissioner accepted that this expectation of confidence is the cornerstone of the Council’s relationships with its clients and is vital for successful service provision. The Commissioner also accepted that the threat of onward disclosure of such information could inhibit the relationship between it and its clients, in that concerns that private information may subsequently be open to public scrutiny may cause clients to be unwilling or to refuse to disclose important information.

On the other elements of the section 41 exemption, the Commissioner relied on the Tribunal decision in Bluck (see above) to rule that the duty of confidence survived the death of the deceased and disclosure of the information would be an actionable breach of confidence. The personal representative of the deceased (the carer) had a theoretical right to sue the council.

Sometimes information being requested about the deceased includes health records which may be accessible under the Access to Health Records Act 1990 .  In such cases the exemption under section 21 of FOI may be claimed i.e. it is reasonably accessible by other means. Section 3 of the 1990 Act gives, amongst others, the personal representatives of the deceased, a right to access the health records of the deceased. Exceptions exist under section 4, e.g. where the patient had requested a note be made that they did not wish access to be given, and section 5.

Before applying the section 21 exemption, a public authority must carefully consider if the applicant indeed has a right of access under the 1990 Act as it only applies in limited circumstances. Firstly, If the requestor is not a personal representative of the deceased (or, to be technically correct, a person having a claim arising out of the death of the deceased) then they cannot access the information under the 1990 Act. Secondly the records being requested, must be health records within the meaning of the Act. A recent Tribunal decision sheds more light on these points.

In Martyres v ICO and NHS Cambridgeshire, EA/2011/020, the requestor sought all information held by NHS Cambridgeshire (and its relevant community services provider), in respect of her deceased mother including information about the care received by her mother at a care home she was staying at prior to her death. The requestor argued that she was the next of kin, proposed executor and trustee of one of the wills and had a valid claim against her mother’s estate under the intestacy rules.

Before the Tribunal, the requestor argued that the Commissioner had erred in concluding that the disputed information was exempt under section 41, as no actionable Breach of Confidence would arise from the disclosure of the information. The Tribunal gave short shrift to this argument and this is not surprising given previous cases discussed above. Strangely it concluded that the confidence was owed to the social workers! I would have thought that it was more owed to the deceased. After all, it was information about her care and the social workers were acting in a professional capacity.

The requestor also contended that the Commissioner should have found that the exemption under section 21 was engaged on the basis that “as next of kin and nearest relative” she would have been entitled to obtain the disputed information under the 1990 Act. The Tribunal disagreed. Whilst she was the nearest relative, she was not the personal representative and so had no rights under the 1990 Act. Furthermore the records being sought were not covered by the 1990 Act as they were not health records. Section 1 of the 1990 Act states that a “health record” is defined as a record which:

“consists of information relating to the physical or mental health of an individual who can be identified from that information, or from that and other information in the possession of the holder of the record; and has been made by or on behalf of a health professional in connection with the care of that individual” (my emphasis)

“Health professional” under the 1990 Act has the same meaning as in the Data Protection Act 1998 (DPA). The Tribunal found that social care professionals do not fall within the list of health professionals under Section 69 of the DPA.

The Trust confirmed that the information held had not been prepared by or on behalf of a healthcare professional. Therefore the Tribunal found that the requestor would not have been able to obtain the disputed information from the Trust under the 1990 Act and that the Commissioner was correct to conclude that the disputed information was not reasonably accessible by other means resulting in the fact that the section 21 exemptions would not be engaged.

This case shows the importance of local authorities and NHS organisations checking to see what is being requested (i.e. a health record or a social work record) and checking that the requestor has a right of access under the 1990 Act. If the answer to either question is in the negative then the request has to be considered in the light of section 41 (Breach of Confidence) i.e. the question has to be asked, would disclosure of the social work records lead to an actionable breach of confidence?

For more on access to information about the deceased read Ibrahim Hasan’s full article here

ISEB Certificate In Freedom of Information

June 2012 – London and Manchester

Do you want to learn about FOI quickly?

Do you want to gain an internationally recognised FOI qualification?

Do you have a limited training budget?

More Information available on our website or email us.

 

FOI Can Make You Money

Ibrahim Hasan has done a guest blog post for the Save FOI Blog. He says…

“Many public authorities have expressed concerns about the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOI) being “abused” by the private sector. They have cited examples of information requests where they are effectively asked to do unpaid research or to supply facts, figures and statistics, which are then repackaged and sold on for profit with little return for the authorities. Many have taken the opportunity to present evidence to the Justice Select Committee  about the cost of dealing with FOI requests. Although some of the figures cited are somewhat dubious, there seems to be groundswell of opinion that the price of openness and transparency is too high. But how many of the same public authorities have considered the forthcoming changes to the FOI regime which may well assist in defraying some of the costs?

The Protection of Freedoms Bill will provide an opportunity for public authorities to raise much-needed revenue from the licensing of some information released pursuant to FOI requests.

READ MORE: http://savefoi2012.wordpress.com/

Freedom of Information Workshops from Act Now Training Ltd
Venues: London, Manchester, Cardiff, Birmingham
Click here for more details

Marion. The FOI exemption for schools.


We delivered some training today to a school in the north – we have a briefing for schools covering DP & FOI in a half day – and as usual prior to the training we did some research which included making a FOI request to the school. Right at the very end of the afternoon after the case studies and the questions the trainer asked if the school had received any FOI requests in the last 7 years. The head teacher sitting bravely on the front row shook his head. Others chimed in and consensus was milliseconds away when the trainer showed on the screen the screen grab of the request that had been made by email 19 days ago using the school’s contact us page.

Silence and almost simultaneously darkness fell.

‘Looks like a request to me” intoned the trainer, “it’s asked for a biography of the Headteacher and details of his reimbursement package for the last financial year”.

Then Marion the school secretary who’d been sitting at the back spoke. “I might have seen that one” she chirped, ” but I delete anything that looks dodgy”.

“What’s dodgy?” ventured the trainer,

“The name, the email address – I don’t allow hotmail ever”, replied the determined administrator.

The trainer tested out a few requests that he knew had been sent to schools in general – the knife incident request, “deleted that” , The CRB question, “deleted that” and the realisation that Marion had set up a foiwall that had yet to be penetrated settled on the room.

Add in the lack of publication scheme, lack of privacy policy and lack of training and it’s clear there’s a lot of work to do in schools. We have a range of services from an online session to a full day in school with audit, policy work & training. See our website.

Marion is of course a pseudonym. Her real name was Margery.

Audio Newsletter

Are you tired of reading long newsletters? 

Listen to the latest Information law stories/cases in bitesize chunks in our audio section.

New items include commentary on latest Commissioner and Tribunal decisions.

http://www.actnow.org.uk/content/25

Just click or scan the QR Code to listen.

Act Now Book Draw Week 1

Book DrawThe winner of the first Act Now Book Draw was Jennifer Green from Babergh Council.

This week’s book is The Freedom of Information Act 2000 by Michael Supperstone QC and Timothy Pitt-Payne.

The next draw will take place on Wednesday 29th Feb at 9 am. Click here to enter the draw.

If you enter the draw and win, you give us permission to let others know that you have won (by e mail, on our website and by Twitter). If you do not want us to do this, please do not enter the draw. Any information we receive through this free draw will not be used for any other purpose.